The government has defended the rights of an Indian couple in Norway. It has spoken out against the attack on the Gita, in the name of the Hindu community, it has joined issue with the U.S over an insult to the sikh community, but when it comes to the thousands who lost their lives in Bhopal, because of the actions of one company, the Indian political establishment has been silent so much so , that this man, Larry Gardnier a UK labour MP is puzzled by India's silence.