Judge Rules Kesha Defamed br Dr. Luke in Text to Lady Gaga According to 'Page Six,' a judge ruled that the br singer defamed Dr. Luke when she told br Lady Gaga that he raped Katy Perry. Supreme Court Justice Jennifer Schecter, via 'Page Six' Supreme Court Justice Jennifer Schecter, via 'Page Six' Supreme Court Justice Jennifer Schecter, via 'Page Six' Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Jennifer Schecter br denied Kesha's counterclaim that she should be released br from a contract with Dr. Luke's KMI record company. She was ordered to pay her former producer br $373,000 in interest for her late payment for br over $1.3 million in royalties. The ruling came amid an ongoing defamation br case where the producer claimed Kesha falsely br accused him of drugging and raping her.