➾ Full review @ - OtterBox Universal Commuter Case for iPhone 4Sbr br Tried the Otterbox Defender case but it was just junk since it used a built in plastic screen cover as opposed to a stick on like this one. It allowed dirt to get between the phone and case which scratched the glass. The Defender was very bulky in comparison but this one still seems to provide good protection even though it is slimmer. br br Overall fit and finish of this product is great and a vast improvement over the Defender case due to slim design, all around protection and a STICK ON screen protector.